The Rise of Online Learning — Reading

Passage

A Distance education did not begin with the internet. Isaac Pitman taught shorthand by correspondence from 1840, posting exercises to students who returned them for marking, and the University of London began awarding degrees to external candidates in 1858. The University of South Africa has taught entirely at a distance since 1946, and Britain's Open University, founded in 1969, enrolled tens of thousands of students who had no formal qualifications at all. The internet changed the cost and the speed of distribution. It did not invent the idea, and the older institutions had already solved problems the newer ones would rediscover. B The excitement of 2012, when several universities launched free online courses to enrolments in the hundreds of thousands, rested on a confusion between registering and studying. Completion rates settled at somewhere between three and fifteen per cent depending on how completion was defined, and the students who finished were overwhelmingly graduates already — people who had learned how to organise their own study before arriving. The technology reached people it had not previously reached; it did not by itself teach them. C What the completion figures obscure is that many enrolments were never intended to end in completion. A working engineer who watches four lectures on a specific technique and stops has obtained exactly what she came for. Judged as a library rather than as a degree, the picture is considerably more favourable, and providers eventually adjusted their own metrics accordingly — though only after the low numbers had become embarrassing. D Evidence on effectiveness is consistent and unglamorous. Fully online courses produce outcomes slightly worse on average than classroom equivalents, and the gap is widest for students who are least prepared — the opposite of what a technology promoted as democratising was supposed to achieve. Blended arrangements, combining online material with scheduled contact, generally outperform both. The mechanism appears to be structure rather than medium: what predicts success is the presence of deadlines, cohorts and someone who notices absence. E Two costs are habitually understated. Producing a good online course is expensive, often exceeding the cost of teaching the same material conventionally for several years, and the recording dates quickly in fast-moving subjects. And assessment at a distance is genuinely hard. Remote proctoring software, which monitors a candidate's camera and keystrokes, has attracted sustained objection on privacy grounds and has been shown to flag disabled and dark-skinned candidates disproportionately. F The credential question has proved more stubborn than the teaching one. Employers reward qualifications partly for what holders learned and partly as a signal of selection and persistence, and a certificate available to anyone who enrols carries little of the second. Providers responded by adding paid verified tracks, proctored examinations and university-badged microcredentials — reintroducing, step by step, most of the gatekeeping the model was launched to abolish. G What has settled is neither replacement nor failure. Online delivery is now routine inside conventional institutions, has made specific professional updating far easier, and works well for motivated adults with prior education. The students the model was most loudly promised to — those without qualifications, money or study habits — remain the ones it serves least well, which was also true of correspondence courses in 1840. H The economics of online course provision have also shifted in a direction few of the early platforms anticipated. Massive open online courses, or MOOCs, launched in the early 2010s on the premise of free access to university-level teaching for anyone with an internet connection, and completion rates for the free, open version have consistently been low — commonly under ten per cent of enrollees finish a given course. What has proven commercially durable is not the free offering but a paid layer built on top of it: verified certificates, credentialed short courses and, increasingly, full degree programmes delivered primarily online but priced closer to campus tuition than to the free ideal the format began with. Several major platforms now generate most of their revenue from institutional and employer-funded training rather than individual learners, a quiet pivot from the original mission of democratising elite education toward something closer to a corporate training vendor with a university-branded catalogue. The free courses still exist and are still used, but they increasingly function as a funnel toward paid credentials rather than as the platforms' central purpose.

বাংলা অনুবাদ জমা দেওয়ার পর দেখা যাবে — আগে ইংরেজিতে বোঝার চেষ্টা করুন।